Is CBAM a carbon tax?

Is CBAM a carbon tax?

Are you looking for the right CSRD solution?
Use our guides and database with +100 CSRD solutions.
Learn more
Need help with CSRD? Here is an overview.
Do you have to comply with CSRD?
Download our Free CSRD Guide now.
Learn more

The European Union's new Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) is not technically a carbon tax, but rather a mechanism that aims to regulate carbon emissions through the imposition of a tax on certain carbon-intensive imports. This mechanism is a significant step in the EU's climate neutrality efforts and is designed to level the playing field for European producers adhering to strict environmental standards.

What is CBAM?

The Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) is an initiative implemented by the European Union as part of its Green Deal. It aims to reduce carbon emissions by applying a carbon price equivalent to the EU's internal regulatory price on certain imports. The mechanism targets carbon-intensive goods such as steel, aluminum, and electricity, with the goal of encouraging global industries to adopt greener technologies.

How does CBAM work?

CBAM works by aligning import tariffs on specific products from non-EU and non-EFTA countries with the carbon price paid under the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS). Initially, CBAM will cover goods like iron, steel, cement, aluminum, electricity, and hydrogen, with the scope expected to expand by 2030. Importers will be required to report quarterly on imported CBAM goods, their emissions, and the carbon price in the country of origin. The full implementation of CBAM, including the need for import authorization and annual declarations, will start in 2026.

Controversies and concerns

The implementation of CBAM has sparked controversy and concern among major trading partners and raises issues around potential impacts on international trade relations and compliance challenges for businesses. Critics argue that CBAM could be protectionist and disproportionately affect developing countries. These countries, with limited input into CBAM's structure, may face high compliance costs and challenges due to their smaller economies and limited regulatory capacities.

A more inclusive approach

To address the shortcomings of CBAM and promote a more inclusive and effective approach to global carbon pricing and climate justice, there is a suggestion to create a Global Sustainable Trade Fund. This fund would be financed by carbon border adjustments and aimed at supporting the most affected countries in their decarbonization efforts. This recommendation aims to ensure that the burden of carbon pricing is shared more equitably and that developing countries receive the necessary support to transition to more sustainable practices.

Conclusion

The European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) is not a carbon tax but a mechanism that aims to regulate carbon emissions through the imposition of a tax on certain carbon-intensive imports. While it is a significant step in the EU's climate neutrality efforts, it has raised concerns and controversies. To address these concerns and promote a more inclusive approach, the creation of a Global Sustainable Trade Fund is suggested. This fund would provide support to developing countries in their decarbonization efforts and ensure a more equitable distribution of the costs and benefits of carbon pricing.

A step-by-step guide to selecting the right CSRD solution.

Screen around 100 CSRD solutions in minutes not weeks, and create an individualized list of solutions.

A laptop showing the CSRD solution finder guide.